My final research project will be
based on the novel The Perks of Being a
Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky. This novel encompasses a large variety of
adolescent issues without sacrificing the narrative or becoming overwhelming.
The protagonist Charlie represents the brink of adolescence at the beginning of
the novel, and although he still exhibits some innocence towards the end, he
grows into a more experienced and mature young adult by the end of the novel. Similar
to The Catcher in the Rye, Charlie
ends the story in a mental institution. However, rather than having the cynical
mindset of Holden Caulfield, Charlie’s character presents a dynamic of being a
hypersensitive teenager in a rather insensitive atmosphere – high school. The
novel addresses the adolescent issues of identity, sexuality, religion, abusive
relationships, sex, child molestation, drug use, sexism and feminism, death,
suicide, depression and anxiety, and overall maturation.
Despite
Charlie’s timid demeanor, he proves to be compassionate and mature for his age,
supported by his friendships formed with the high school seniors Patrick and
Sam as well as his short love interest with Mary Elizabeth. He shows a struggle
to find his identity as he begins the novel writing letters to an unnamed
character – taking the similar “if you want to hear about it” tone Holden
Caulfield uses. Charlie writes the letters to cope with the recent loss of his
only friend Michael to suicide, and expresses his nervousness as he is about to
begin high school. Losing a close friend to suicide at the age of fifteen right
on the brink of beginning at a new school allows the audience to witness
Charlie’s character development as he befriends his older classmates as well as
his English teacher.
Sexuality
is a common adolescent issue dealt with throughout the novel. This is
introduced through many of the characters. The relationship between Patrick and
Brad addresses the difficulties and complications that come with homosexual
relationships in high school with the added element that Brad is still in the
closet due to his homophobic father. Candace, possibly taking after their Aunt
Helen, enters an abusive relationship and is caught by Charlie having sex with
him in the basement. Sam expresses that she used to be (and still is by her
peers) considered “easy” and would use partying as a coping mechanism for her
low self esteem. She does not seem to have gotten over this completely as she
dates an older boy in the novel who treats her condescendingly and ends up
cheating on her. Charlie begins to develop sexual desires towards Sam but
cannot act on them since she has a boyfriend, causing him to pursue Mary
Elizabeth somewhat against his will. When he finally kisses Sam though, this
evokes repressed memories of Aunt Helen molesting him as a child, giving the
emphasized bond he felt towards his Aunt Helen a new meaning.
Death
becomes a central theme to the novel as well since it begins with Michael’s
suicide and Charlie’s frustration that he was unaware of what Michael was going
through. Charlie also expresses several times how much he loves and misses his
Aunt Helen who died in a car accident on Charlie’s birthday, causing him to
think it was his fault. Charlie harbors a lot of guilt and blame for both
deaths of people so important to him, providing insight as to why he is such a
people-pleasing character throughout the novel. He struggles to identify
himself outside of these tragedies and the comfort of his friends, which also ties
into his later drug use in the novel.
In addition
to this being an adolescent novel, age becomes a central theme as well. Charlie
attempts to place his identity in the form of age as he counts down how many
days he has left of high school. He befriends his English professor who is much
older as well as surrounding himself with seniors. The relationship with his
English teacher could be seen as Bill taking on the parental role that Charlie never
fully had as his own father seems cold and removed. He bonded the most with his
aunt before she passed away, idolizes his brother who is in college, and
attends parties mixed with high-school students and college students. Both of
his romantic interests are at least three years older than he is, which is
partially why he gets into drug use as well.
Drug use is
slightly addressed in the novel as well, although it is not expanded on as much
as the other issues. Charlie tries LSD at a party, causing him to have an
existential crisis of questioning if he is too different from the others. This sparks
the revelation that he has suppressed memories of tragedy which becomes
relevant again during a brutal fight in the cafeteria. These issues all begin
to intertwine as his drug problem sheds light on his memory suppression which exposes
his childhood molestation and traumatic bonding with his Aunt Helen.
While the
novel tackles many different problems posed by the transition from childhood
into adulthood, it does so in a way that mirrors the reality of these issues
accurately. However, since the demographic is white middle class, it does not
represent race or a wide range of economic status well. The social issues
represented exist only within a certain construct making the novel relatable on
some level to all teens, but more so to the teens who have similar backgrounds
as those in the novel. Also, although it is not explicitly stated other than
the suppression of memories, it could be assumed that Charlie has some form of
social anxiety or a type of social disorder. He has trouble forming
relationships and seems to bond with the group of seniors solely on the fact
that he acts different and is as much of a misfit as they are. The concept of
identity has more depth in this sense since it is applicable to not only the
protagonist, but to his circle of peers and family members as well.
Hi Erin,
ReplyDeleteThis text certainly has a lot to work with. I don't get a clear sense from your post of what it is that you would like to pursue in this text, and adolescent identity is too broad for a focus for a term paper. It seems that most of the scholarship on Perks of Being a Wallflower deals with the epistolary form of the novel. Angel Matos' "Writing through Growth and Growth through Writing" and Emily Wasserman's "The Epistolary in Young Adult Literature" may be good places to start, just to see how other scholarship discusses this text and to skim their works cited for more sources. You can supplement scholarship on the novel with scholarship from whichever field you decide to pursue. For example, I think the portrayal of mental health and illness in these coming-of-age novels is interesting. With a novel like this that is often compared to The Catcher in the Rye, you may also want to look through scholarship on The Catcher in the Rye because it may well be relevant to your topic. You might want to check out Lawrence Ziewacz' "Holden Caulfield, Alex Portnoy, and Good Will Hunting: Coming of Age in American Films and Novels." You may be able to find an angle on this boys' coming-of-age novel that intertwines trauma, queerness, and mental disturbance/disorders.
Also, check out Cassidy Sizemore's post and the comments on her Individual Text Feature because she is working with the same text.
DeleteHi Erin!
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your post on Perks, and I think you have a good scope of all the possible topics you could work with in your paper. I would definitely recommend choosing just one theme, expanding on it, and possibly comparing that theme with another book we have read in class, since you mentioned The Catcher in the Rye. Also, Charlie has a particular fondness for The Catcher in the Rye in the novel, describing it as "the type of book you make your own." I might suggest looking into "Finding Holden in Contemporary YA Literature" by Steven T Bickmore. It also seems that Perks has been banned in many libraries due to its exploration of several adult themes, similar to Catcher in the Rye.
Here is the link to the article if you are interested:
http://uh7qf6fd4h.search.serialssolutions.com/?ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=It%27s+The+Catcher+in+the+Rye%E2%80%A6+He+said+it+was+the+kind+of+book+you+made+your+own%27%3A+Finding+Holden+in+Contemporary+YA+Literature&rft.jtitle=English+in+Education&rft.au=Bickmore%2C+Steven+T&rft.au=Youngblood%2C+Kate&rft.date=2014-09-01&rft.issn=0425-0494&rft.eissn=1754-8845&rft.volume=48&rft.issue=3&rft.spage=250&rft.epage=263&rft_id=info:doi/10.1111%2Feie.12049&rft.externalDocID=EIE12049¶mdict=en-US
Hi Erin,
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your chosen text and I think that your ideas can go in various directions. The most compelling point you make however is the dynamics of various sexual relationships. I think that you should stray from the other ideas and perhaps hone in heteronormativity, homosexuality, and age in the context of sex. Sex in and of itself as a topic for your individual text feature, specifically with this text, is, in my opinion, the best way to approach the assignment.
I also don't buy into the Catcher in the Rye parallels and I think that is going to be difficult to write a nuanced argument as to how they relate. I would also suggest delving into the evolvement of sexuality in YA lit.
ReplyDelete