For my final project, I will be
dealing with The Giver by Lois Lowry.
The book, told from a third-person omniscient narrator, centers around a boy
named Jonas. He lives in a future society that is so heavily controlled that at
one point, when a pilot flies by, he is brought down and then “released” from
the compound, which is basically a form of capital punishment in their society.
The people around Jonas are extremely concerned with the language they use and
actions they make. They stress telling the truth all the time, as well as using
precise diction to pinpoint their exact feelings about a situation. At the
beginning of the book, Jonas is described as feeling “apprehensive.” He is
eleven years old, and will soon participate in the “Ceremony of the Twelve,” in
which he will find out what his permanent profession will be.
It’s at this point that the reader
learns the details of Jonas’s society. Every year, 50 babies are born and
distributed to families. Each family is allowed one boy and one girl, no more
and no less. As children grow, the celebrate ceremonies each year in a communal
birthday party of sorts—meaning every child celebrates their birthday on the
same day as everyone else. There is little room for individuality within this society,
something we later learn Jonas has trouble with. The society is filled with
specific rules set by the Elders and another leader, a mysterious person called
The Receiver. The Elders watch the youth closely and decide what their jobs
should be. After they are assigned, it’s off to work, with little to no time
for personal concerns.
Jonas’s father is a Nurturer,
meaning he looks after newborn babies. One in particular may have to be “released”
because he’s showing signs of sickness. Jonas’s father brings the baby, named
Gabriel, home for some extra nurturing. The baby, like Jonas, has light eyes,
an oddity in a community of dark-eyed people. Later, Jonas recalls another
instance in which he felt different than others: when he was tossing around an
apple and saw it “change.” Lowry leaves it at that for the time being. The
story shifts to Jonas putting in volunteer hours with his friends Asher and
Fiona at the old folks home. While at the home, Jonas talks with a woman named
Larissa about a “release” of an old man that happened earlier that day. The two
question the rules of the release ceremony and Larissa describes the man as
looking happy to be released.
As the novel continues, Jonas notes
more and more oddities in his community. One example comes in his dreams. When
he has a sexually-charged dream about Fiona, he is given a pill to forget it.
Jonas notes that he doesn’t really want to take the pill.
Finally, the time has come for his
ceremony. After waiting through all the rest of the ceremonies, Jonas eagerly
steps up to receive his assignment and is shocked when his name is skipped in
the order of assignments. Finally, the Elder conducting the ceremony comes back
to Jonas at the end and declares that he will be the next Receiver. He notes
that the current Receiver has light eyes, too. The changing apple is finally
explained: apparently Jonas has something called the “capacity to see beyond.”
Jonas nervously accepts his assignment. After the ceremony, Jonas learns the
last person they chose to replace the Receiver was a “failure,” so much so that
her name isn’t used anymore. Jonas also receives his training instructions:
where to go, what his schedule is, and the added perks of being able to be rude
to people, withhold his dreams, and lie. All of these things are very odd in a
society of rigid rules.
Jonas reports to training, where he
learns that he will be Receiving memories from the whole world from the current
Receiver. He will be a keeper of all things: of history, memory, pain, joy,
etc. Jonas gets the memory of snow and sunshine and sunburn. The old Receiver
has now become the Giver. As Jonas gains memories of colors and events and
individualism, he wonders why all of those things were cut out. The Giver
explains that the people in charge gave up pretty things like color and
diversity in exchange for control and “sameness.” Jonas feels frustrated
because of the lack of choice in their society, which the Giver claims is in
place to protect people from making the wrong choices. As Jonas acquires more
memories, he learns more about society. He learns of the failed Receiver who’s
memories were released into the world. We learn the Giver’s primary purpose is
to suffer on the behalf of the rest of society.
Jonas gains more painful memories,
like hunger and war. He wonders about Elsewhere (the place people go when “released”).
The more memories he gets, the more he questions his society. Meanwhile,
Gabriel get healthier—although Jonas accidentally transmits a memory to him. As
Jonas learns more about an old way of life filled with big families, love,
choices, and colors, he tells Jonas he wishes things were still that way. He realizes
people around him have never experienced emotions, which upsets him. A year of
training goes by, during which Jonas realizes “release” is synonymous with “lethal
injection.” He and the Giver devise a plan for him to fake his death and run
away to Elsewhere, allowing his memories to be released to society, thus
restoring choice and emotion to the world. As he is about to leave, he learns
Gabriel is going to be released, so he takes the baby with him to Elsewhere.
After a long journey fraught with cold and hunger, Jonas and Gabriel reach
Elsewhere, where people are waiting to see them as the book closes.
This book looks at a myriad of
themes and subjects in adolescent literature. Some of the most prominent are
death, sexual freedom, individualism, oppressive systems, and diversity. I
think the most compelling topic presented by The Giver is the idea of total equality. Jonas lives in an entirely
homogenous society, with little to no room for individualism. “Finding oneself”
or becoming an individual is often associated with a child “coming of age.” Throughout
the novel, Jonas finds small pieces of his own humanity in the communal
memories he gains from the Giver. As he grows and learns about society, he
begins to question it. He realizes he has been living as a piece in the system
for many years and desires to not only break himself out, but play the hero and
break out society as a whole. I am interested in exploring the idea of personal and societal power structures and patterns of adolescents breaking out of these structures. I think this text also highlights the need for diversity and the harm that can come from removing diversity from society. I would like to further examine that and relate it back to the theme of individuality.
Hi Rebekah,
ReplyDeleteThe Giver is a classic of adolescent literature precisely because it deals with so many of these important issues of identity, maturation, and development. The main stumbling block to working with The Giver is that so much has already been written about it. You will have to pore through a lot of research to find your niche. For example, the theme of diversity vs. sameness is explored in the articles "Seeing Beyond Sameness:Using the Giver to Challenge Colorblind Ideology" and "Making Meaning of Cultural Depictions: Using Lois Lowry's The Giver to Reconsider What is Multicultural about Literature." One of the more interesting and debated pieces of The Giver is the ambiguous ending. Much like the Chocolate War, critics are divided on whether or not Jonas is dead at the end. "On the Possibility of Elsewhere: A Postsecular Reading of Lois Lowry's The Giver Trilogy" and "Lois Lowry's The Giver: Interrupted Bildungsroman or Ambiguous Dystopia" are good places to start for that debate. Finally, you may also consider the entire Trilogy when developing your argument. Many arguments about The Giver end with the first book, but she does develop the series beyond that.
Rebekah, you should also read my comment on Jacob's post, just above yours.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much!!
ReplyDeleteHey Rebekah,
ReplyDeleteIm also working with The Giver. I think it would be interesting to look at the personal/societal power structures in the novel. Like Kristen mentioned, the ambiguous ending would also be interesting to explore.
One article that might give you some ideas about the power structures in the novel is "Discipline and Its Discontents: A Foucauldian Reading of The Giver" by Latham, Don
Good luck on your paper and research!