Gabrielle Scott
"Me and Earl and the Dying Girl"
By Jesse Andrews
The novel, “Me and Earl and the Dying Girl” by Jesse Andrews
is told in the perspective of a senior in high school named Greg Gaines. For
his entire high school career, he has chosen to remain a member of all groups
that attend Benson High School. Greg feels that as difficult as this is to
maintain, gaining access to every group avoids the excess drama that high
school has to offer. While he aims to remain fairly invisible without a label,
his view of the world will shift towards the end of the book. His seemingly
easy-going and uncaring attitude is at many times humorous, which this books
offers plenty of. Although it is about a dying girl, Greg’s humor tends to
overthrow the sadness of what the character Rachel Kushner has been diagnosed
with.
One
day, when Greg gets home, his mother abruptly tells him that Rachel, a former
girl he had been dating, has a rare form of Leukemia. At first, of course, he
is not certain what this means, and he does not seem to grasp the gravity of
what his mother is seemingly forcing him to do. She begs him to hang out and be
a good friend to Rachel, who is alone while suffering from this newfound diagnosis.
When Greg tries a couple of times on the phone, and even being funny about it,
Rachel does not want to. Greg’s mother insists and will not allow him to drop
the idea of trying. Eventually Rachel obliges. At first Greg is uncomfortable
and does not enjoy being around Rachel. There is an odd elephant in the room
that always seems to hang around because Greg comes face to face with the
knowledge of illness and death for the first time. Her illness serves as a
platform for Greg to shift his perspectives and change his way of living. While
he originally sees his life as almost dull, being forced to see Rachel leads
him to grow.
He
begins to spend nearly all of his free time with her, ignoring his homework.
She pushes him to apply for a college when he admits that he does not know what
to do with his life. Greg feels that the movies he makes with his friend Earl
are not the best quality, but Rachel spends her time watching them. Earl is his
best friend from a young age that he spends most of his time with, other than
spending time with Rachel. Earl also pushes him to move away from his less than
realistic views. Although they are very different, Earl plays an important role
in Greg’s life.
He is at times embarrassed about
the movies he makes, and does not want anyone else to see them. In this way,
Rachel is doing what no one else has for Greg- building his confidence. He
certainly does not have any confidence in himself before hanging out with
Rachel, but her company leads to Greg having a deeper appreciation for what
life has to offer. He continues to find out about Rachel after she has died,
which makes Greg realize that a person can still live on if memories of them
are maintained.
Though
Rachel fights in the beginning of her cancer, she begins to accept death rather
than going through chemotherapy. While she initially goes through a mourning
phase, she deals with the idea because she knows that her stage four cancer is
tough to beat. Greg does not accept her attitude towards death because he feels
that she is giving up. He tells her to keep fighting and while he is sulking
feeling sorry for himself, Rachel is suffering from the graver circumstance. He
is forced to change that attitude when everyone else around who knew of Rachel
and cared about her tries to tell him to knock himself out of it. Another girl
named Madison tells him he should make a movie for Rachel, and he plays the
video for her in the hospital when he was about to go to Prom with Madison.
Throughout
the book, Greg does not accept the fact that Rachel will die because he
continues to say that she will live. When he is forced to come to terms with
reality, he begins to see that all along he was falling in love with her. The
saying is true that you miss what is already gone, and this makes coping with
the loss of her difficult on him. His perspective shifts from not really caring
about others and the world around him, other than hot girls he likes but cannot
seem to gain the attraction back, to his life being impacted by the “dying
girl.” His mother making him hang out with Rachel was what Greg needed to
change his life around. He avoided homework during school and views his
relationship with Rachel at first as a burden. He is accepted into a
University, but his application is rescinded when he does not maintain his
grade point average. Rachel writes a letter to them, and Greg writes the book
about his experience, which is how the book is written. It is from the
perspective of Greg telling a story about his senior year and how he changed
from the impact of Rachel’s death. He writes this book to send it into the
college so they can possibly readmit him.
This
book touches upon many aspects of being a teenager. The awkwardness, the sudden
realization that life is not everlasting, the prospect of death and what that
can do to others around you and how it can change a person, the realization
that a certain way of living needs to change, and how humor ties all of these
aspects of being an adolescent together. This is the reason why this book is doing critical work in the field of adolescent literature. In Greg’s novel, he stumbles along the way to try and find out what he really wants to do with his life with his impending adulthood. I am teetering between many ideas of what my argument could be about. Since there are many aspects of adolescent novels in one book, there are many perspectives I could speak of. For instance, I could argue that teenagers feel nearly invincible and that death “can’t touch them,” but once they encounter someone dying and the realization that death will happen, they change their perspective and grow. Certainly, Greg learns his place in the world and begins to become acquainted with his identity. There is also a quite of bit of nonsense tied into the weightier subject of death, but overall I think my argument could be related to Greg changing once he realizes that Rachel chooses to die and how that impacts him.
Hi Gabrielle,
ReplyDeleteYes, you can certainly work with the theme of encountering and accepting death in adolescent literature with this novel. To me, what seems most interesting or promising about this novel's representation of death and bereavement is the way in which death and erotic desire are intertwined. He realizes that he is in love with her after she is dead and it many ways falls in love with her from watching her die. This taps into old themes of death and desire. I would begin by checking out Death, Gender, and Sexuality in Contemporary Adolescent Literature by Kathryn James. We have a copy in UF'S Education Library. I would start there, and with Trites' chapter on death to help you parcel out your own argument on how death is connected to desire and maturation in this novel.
Hey Gabrielle,
ReplyDeleteFrom what I can tell, and as Kristen mentioned in her comment under my original post, we're writing about similar topics! I am writing about "Looking for Alaska" by John Green. I think we could definitely use each other's novels as supplemental sources in our papers as they both deal with death and sexuality/desire in adolescents. I also was planning on utilizing some of John Green's other novels like "The Fault in Our Stars." That being said, I am trying to expand my options beyond the stereotypical "Adolescent Death" novels. "13 Reasons Why" and "If I Stay" are a couple of other titles that I'm looking into that might help you as well! I like your angle that pertains to change after death, as it is very common to discuss the death itself without acknowledging the aftereffects it has on the surrounding people.
I think the concept of death is a very prevalent topic in adolescent literature and lots of books touch on coping with death and give young adults a basis of understanding it. Identity crises are a growing part of any adolescent experience, and Greg having to find himself while dealing with the death of Rachel. I find the part about the concepts surrounding death being explained in humour especially interesting, since it is the way that I would go about talking about these topics if I were an adolescent writer. One source you may find helpful is about death in adolescent literature, here's the link: https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/ALAN/fall99/radley.html
ReplyDeleteGood Luck on your final paper!
Hi Gabrielle,
ReplyDeleteI think you're headed in a good direction for your paper. I agree with you assertion that many adolescents have a sense of invincibility that will ultimately disappear once they are challenged by death and I think a way to expand on this concept is by focusing on how literature can be used as the catalyst for that change. This leads to the question of why literature has to do that in the first place which raises the question of how death is represented and taught about. Therefore, I think a piece of scholarship that can help you out is Phillipe Aries's Western Attitudes About Death, which gives a historical breakdown of how death is represented. I believe that by studying the trends in how death is seen, you can discuss why Greg is so affected and how books like Me, Earl, & the Dying Girl help real adolescents face such subjects