The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian
This novel
encapsulates a lot about young adult literature because it combines
easy-to-read language and humour into a lifelong lesson. The life that Sherman
Alexie wants to convey talks about the struggles that he as a native American
faces, and how he was able to cope with not only his own disabilities at birth
and as a kid, but also as a member of a reservation, which he affectionately
calls “the rez.” The reason why Alexie sees himself as so hopeless is not only
because he was born with too much “brain grease,” but also because he had to be
born as a Native American on a reservation to boot. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian gives adolescents a
story about an awkward kid in school while simultaneously showing the struggles
of Indian life on and off a reservation.
The
beginning of the novel introduces Arnold Spirit Junior as the protagonist and
we immediately get plunged into his trials and tribulations as a
fourteen-year-old boy on a Spokane Indian reservation. Arnold feels as though
there is no one in the world that cares about him, and that he is worth less
than nothing. He is an awkward looking teenager with “ten extra teeth” and a
lisp due to his deformities at birth, and is constantly called a “retard” by
all the kids at school. He gets beat up “at least once a month” and can only
see his drawing of cartoons as an escape from the hard life he lives.
Immediately, we are plunged into a tragic story about a boy and his dog, and
the novel paints a much darker picture than it has already. Oscar, Junior’s
dog, is incredibly sick and his family is too poor to take him to a vet. Oscar
was a stray that Junior took in, and he sees him as his best friend who understands
him more than anyone else on the rez. Junior’s father sees the suffering animal
as just that, a suffering animal, and decides it must be put out of it’s
misery. Junior begs and pleads that he would pay his parents back if they could
take him to a vet, but as the novel chillingly states, “a bullet only costs
about two cents, and anyone can afford that.”
After the heart-wrenching loss of Arnold’s
dog, we get introduced to Rowdy as a character. Rowdy is Arnold’s friend from birth
and Arnold considers him one of the toughest Indians on the rez, saying that he
“fought everybody” and had been “born mean.” Rowdy and Arnold both play
basketball together, and they are planning on trying out for the varsity team.
Rowdy and Arnold share a strong friendship throughout the novel, and Rowdy
takes the role of protector when it comes to Arnold. Arnold “betrays” Rowdy by going
to Reardan and leaving the rez school. Rowdy is hurt, and as physical violence
is his strong suit, he punches Arnold out of anger, frustration, and sadness
when he gets the news. When Arnold goes to Reardan, Rowdy does not speak to
Arnold much, and they reconcile their friendship on the basketball court where
they promise to never lose contact no matter what the future holds for either
of them
Another aspect of adolescent
literature that is focused on in this novel is masturbation. Arnold has a brief
section about what things get him sexually excited and has a shameless
description as to what makes him horny and why. He also justifies masturbating
by saying that “everybody does it and everybody likes it” and “God wouldn’t have
given us thumbs if he didn’t want us to masturbate.” So far, Arnold has covered
both the feeling of awkward loneliness, masturbation, and strong friendships,
all very important topics in the field of adolescent literature.
Poverty continues to be a motif in
this novel, and another example is a scene where Arnold is getting his geometry
books from his teacher, Mr. P. Arnold says he is a self-proclaimed “book kisser,”
but as he opens the cover, he sees the name Agnes Adams written in the front
cover. Agnes Adams is his mother’s maiden name, so Arnold realizes that they
are so poor, the reservation schools are teaching them from the same books that
their parents used in school. This prompted Arnold to throw his book at the
front of the class, but ended with him hitting Mr. P in the face and being
suspended from school. Mr. P and Arnold have a heart-to-heart about forgiving
each other and about Arnold’s sister Mary Runs Away and how she wanted to write
romance novels. Arnold says “there is always time to change your life” and this
is a reoccurring point in the novel.
Transitioning to Reardan, we see
Arnold introduce Penelope, a blue-eyed white girl who he thinks is the most beautiful
woman on Earth. So the concept of talking to girls is shown through Arnold’s
interaction with Penelope, another important aspect of adolescent literature,
more specifically targeted at adolescent boys. Gordy, the other friend Arnold
makes, is an intelligent kid, the “book-smart” kind, and Roger, the school’s
resident jock, eventually grows to respect Arnold after a brief fisticuffs
where Arnold lays him out after Roger make a racist joke. Arnold believed that
violence was the solution when someone insulted you to your face, because that
was the rules on the rez, which he lists in the novel. This “culture clash” is
a clear indicator that the difference between Indian reservation life and white
culture will be a main focus of this novel. Another angle that these interactions takes is
a glimpse into white culture as an Indian who has never experienced it.
The novel takes concepts all too
familiar to the adolescent reader such as sex, love, courage, and helplessness,
and bundles them all under the guise of the life of one Indian kid. The
easy-to-read language and the visual representations of the language in the form
of cartoon drawings lends itself well to the organization and the fluidity of
the novel’s story. The topic of alcoholism is also incredibly present
throughout the novel such as when Arnold’s grandmother is killed by a drunk
driver, and when his sister dies in a mobile home fire after they had been
drinking. The different factors and life lessons that are at play throughout
the novel place this in the category as one of the top adolescent novels of our
time.
Hi Chris,
ReplyDeleteAlexie's book is a fine choice for this project, though you will of course have to have a more specific argument than just that it fits a lot of the critical patterns of adolescent literature. You will want to pick just one of these to build an argument from, so which themes are you most interested in? For example, if you are interested in Alexie's use of humor to relay serious messages about American Indian adolescence, then you may want to begin with Nerida Wayland's "Representations of Happiness in Comedic Young Adult Fiction," which mentions Absolutely True Diary, and Sherman Alexie's interview, "Humor is my Green Card." Or, if you are most interested in the representation of alcoholism in a YA text, you may want to begin with Meagan Lacy's "Portraits of Children of Alcoholics." Basically, you'll want to narrow it down a bit to which topics interest you the most. Maybe choose two or three and then start skimming through the research sources to see which type of argument you want to make.
Chris,
ReplyDeleteI think that you have made a good choice in selecting this novel for your research project. I have not read The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian and after familiarizing myself with the novel through reading some summaries online, I thought that you did a great job in summarizing the main points of the book. The fact that the novel is autobiographical is a fascinating aspect of this novel. If I were you, I would research about Sherman Alexie’s life and give the reader a bit of context and background about the Spokane Indian Reservation. The argument that I find the most interesting is the topic of bullying. Many teens unfortunately experience this throughout their adolescence. The fact that Arnold has a condition which has resulted in deformities and a stutter makes him an easy target. I think this would be a worthwhile point to mention since a lot of adolescent literature centers on this difficult transitional period and highlights bullying. I would also take the time to explain Arnold’s condition so that the reader is fully aware of the extent of his incapacitations. Additionally, you mentioned the idea of masturbation, which is something worth mentioning since most adolescents begin to discover their sexuality during this juncture. I would explore the idea of masturbation through the perspective of life on a reservation in terms of religion and proximity to family. Here are some articles that I have found about this novel that I feel would be helpful for your final project:
https://www.ninds.nih.gov/Disorders/Patient-Caregiver-Education/Fact-Sheets/Hydrocephalus-Fact-Sheet
http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/ALAN/v36n2/crandall.html
Hi Chris! One of my favorite novels that we have read in class is How I Became a Ghost and almost decided to do this book, so I am very happy to see someone else doing it. I think it would be interesting if you touched upon the subject of Arnold as a male, diary-writing narrator. Also, there seems to be a pattern in the need in YA literature for the narrator to be relatable to. However, Arnold identifying as a male seems to be the only typical narrator role, so it would be interesting to see how Arnold, as a disabled Native American, affects the universality of this book. It could be easier to identify with once considering Arnold's attempt to be a part of the white culture. If you choose to focus on theis problem of identity, you should consider reading the article "Hey, I Still Can't See Myself!: The Difficult Positioning of Two-Spirit Identities in YA Literature." There is a focus on dual-identity that is seen in the novel you chose.
ReplyDelete