The issue of identity is a prominent aspect of Kristen
Cashore’s novel, Graceling. Not only is Katsa’s existence somewhat problematic
as her Grace is rather destructive, but her fate is determined by her uncle who
robs her of the ability to define her purpose in life. Katsa’s Grace allows her
to be an excellent fighter. Unfortunately, until Katsa was able to harness her
Grace properly, she ended up killing some people, prompting her to believe that
she was a monster. Moreover, the fact that her uncle has enlisted her as a soldier
of sorts does not aid in the process of self-discovery that all teens must go
through. From my research on gifted children, there are children whose talents
are exploited for the benefit of organizations or leaders. Katsa is gifted in
the sense that she has an extraordinary ability and her uncle capitalizes on
her talent, disregarding her wishes. In Katsa’s case, the emotional abuse that
stems from this exploitation results in confusion and self-deprecation. Additionally,
Katsa challenges traditional gender expectations. Females are often associated
with being subservient individuals whose purpose is to be a mother and wife.
Katsa finds this idea to be repulsive and intends to remain single despite the
disproval she faces by most of the men in her life. The following passage from
Chapter 7 illustrates Katsa’s desire to remain single and the criticism she
encounters:
“Lord Davit,” she said, “have you a wife?”
He shook his head. “It’s the only thing my estate lacks, My
Lady.”
Katsa kept her eyes on her venison and carrots. “My uncle is
very disappointed in me, because I intend never to marry.”
Lord Davit paused, and then spoke. “I doubt your uncle is
the only man who finds that disappointing.”
As one can see, Katsa rejects the idea of marriage,
abandoning the classic gender roles of the time. While the world Katsa lives in
is fictional, the idea of a teenager going against classic ideologies could
definitely have an impact on the readers of this novel. Perhaps an adolescent
who does not want to get married would finally feel like their feelings were
normal after reading this novel; or maybe a teenager would decide that it was
actually alright to remain single throughout their life.
Hi Olivia,
ReplyDeleteThis response comments on two important aspects of Katsa's identity: her giftedness and her gender. You are right that as a gifted adolescent she becomes a tool to be used by her corrupt adult guardian, and it recalls actual trends in America's treatment of gifted children. As a female adolescent, she rebels against the ideas that men have for her future. Is there a way to combine these two facets together into one message on identity? I.e., what does it mean to specifically be a gifted girl? If not, then it probably makes more sense to focus on one or the other for this short response.