Tuesday, March 14, 2017

Brown Girl Dreaming, Category B, Option D

The quote I found the most profound in this text was the quote, “Even the silence has a story to tell you. Just listen: Listen.” This quote was on page 278 of the text and it’s in the chapter called “How to Listen #7”.  This haunting passage comes right after the death of the grandfather in the text. I believe this quote is highlighting how the silence after a tragedy such as this one, shows how much pain everyone is in and that’s why you can hear the story it is telling. This passage immediately reminded me of the song The Silence by the Bastilles. The songs main chorus says:

 Cause it is not enough to be dumbstruck
Can you fill the silence?
You must have the words in that head of yours
Oh, oh, can you feel the silence?
I can't take it anymore,
Cause it is not enough to be dumbstruck, oh

I believe these lyrics also highlight what the author was trying to say in their own passage. Filling the silence is always difficult, especially in situations around jarring life events.  The rest of the song lyrics also relate to this story as well.

For example, when the song says, “tell me a piece of your history” it could correlate to the stories our protagonist longs to tell. When the song says, “Now you’ve hit a wall and you’re lost for words, my dear, my dear, now you’ve hit a wall and you hit it hard, my dear, my dear, my dear, oh dear” that could relate to her grief over the loss of her grandfather and how its caused her to hear the story in the silence.


Link to the Youtube Video with lyrics: https://youtu.be/00p2FW7ZLVo
Link to the Youtube Video performance: https://youtu.be/PaOUqpS9Y6I

2 comments:

  1. Hi Sam,

    This is a great song selection. I agree that the How to Listen poems were powerful throughout the text, but the last one on silence seemed particularly significant given the death of her grandfather. It also reminded me of "The Sound of Silence."

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really appreciate this song selection because of its thoughtfulness. A lot of songs are easy to choose for a scene because of the abundance of music out there, and lyrics that easily fit passages. However, I think that you really took a step back when considering what passage and song to choose. Your choice works well with the scene and it's interesting that you chose to fill silence with silence!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.