Sunday, January 29, 2017

“The Diary of a Young Girl:" Religious Identity


The notion of secrecy is central within the autobiographical novel, “The Diary of a Young Girl.” Just as the Frank family’s secretively resides within the Annex, Anne deems it necessary to conceal a portion of her personal identity because of her Jewish heritage in a society with anti-Semitic beliefs. Although Anne doesn’t express great consideration towards her Jewish heritage, how it largely influences and hiders her is unavoidable. Its hindrance is unavoidable as her status in the Jewish community results in her being forced to experience and act upon an identity that was forced upon her, along many others, as if they were “cattle” (84). Anne is aware of the injustices of Jewish dehumanization and is from that point, she is prompted to ask questions, regarding why people “try so hard to hide their own feelings,” why she “behaves quite differently” from what she “should in other people’s company,” and why everyone trusts “one other so little” (155). It is also over the course of her self-reflecting, diary writing in which she becomes aware of the dichotomy in her identity, which she refers to as “two Annes.” The two sides of her are created out of her feelings of isolation, not only out of the deprived circumstances she has to deal with as a Jew in an anti-Semitic society, but simultaneously because of her adolescence which leads her to fear others misunderstanding her. This is also partially caused because of the lack of people who are able to be there for emotional support within her life, such as her own mother who she feels doesn’t understand her, nor does she take her seriously (138). Anne then wonders if she would ever be able to escape these negative perspectives upon her and her community that identifies her and re-establish herself within her “entire little world of bygone days” (61).

1 comment:

  1. Hi Lydia,

    I agree that Anne's "two Annes" that she references in the diary speaks to her position as an adolescent. It could be because adolescence is a time of temporary transition and so she is caught between child and adult. Her temperamental immature side could be"child Anne" while her thoughtful and well-spoken side is her "adult Anne." I would like to see more evidence for your claim that it is also tied up in her religious identity. Does Anne ever speak about needing to behave differently around non-Jewish people or does the construction of the diary as a novel ask us to see the two Anne's as related to being a Jew in hiding? For future responses, it would also be good to have a mini intro and thesis statement with separate paragraphs, even though they would only be a few sentences, just to make your argument more apparent and organized.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.